I suppose I'll start off with the ridiculously horrible weapons, the ones that people use just because they see others doing it. They never even bother to check the buffs or penalties of using such a weapon, and more often than not, the weapon's penalties far outweighs the buffs.
Then I'll take a look at the buffs and give it a verdict.
Scout
Primary Weapons
Scattergun: Typical run-of-the-mill weapon. By far the best one, so it doesn't really need to be covered at all. Primary Weapons
Force-A-Nature: Taking the Scout's Scattergun and reducing the bullets from six to two, but adding a larger kick to it when it hits enemies. It seems great, doesn't it?
...Yeah, okay, nice cheesy advertising there. Seriously, though, it's not that great. Sure, it has a greater knockback, but that just prevents a Scout from being up close to the target (which is how shotguns are supposed to be used in the first place). Debatably, the damage modifier is greater, but it still does 10% less damage per shot. However, unless you're a good shot or can get up close, missing can prove deadly with only two rounds of fire before reloading for a good amount of time. It's also good to mention that reloading while one bullet is still intact makes that bullet vanish for eternity.
On the plus side, this weapon is perfect for Scout jump maps on TF2. It allows Scout to be able to have a third jump while in the air. It's a great nuisance, especially from behind. Fast shooting and knockback can knock unsuspecting victims into hazards.
Verdict: It's a nicely balanced weapon, but besides TF2 jump maps, Scatter is the way to go.
Shortstop: Taking the Scattergun and reducing six bullets to four inside of a pistol fac simile (peppergun). Only difference is that it is loaded in the primary slot.
Oh, man, that looks sweet! So, wait, what's wrong with it? To start with, it replaces the Scattergun, remember, so that limits the Scout to having two pistols and a bat. The primary pistol shares the same ammo as the secondary, so that's also a loss. Reduced ammo and no more Scattergun. It just sounds stupid and it is. There's absolutely no reason to use this crap weapon, go use the already given secondary pistol. Oh, I forgot, the class bonus. That's for another time though.
The pistol functions horribly as a primary weapon and no matter what it is in conjuction with it still sucks, regardless of whatever its name is.
Verdict: Hunk of junk; waste of space; useless.
Soda Popper: Hey! Look! It's the Force-A-Nature! Only now it has a can of Crit-a-Cola underneath and it looks like some maniac kid ripped it apart, then sloppily put it back together. Six shots are replaced with two shots again.
What are the gains over Force-A-Nature? Two; no random critical hits, no knockback, no additional damage done. All it has is faster reload and if Scout runs enough to fill the "hype" bar he will perform mini-crits. Sounds pretty bad. The benefits of this gun are too minimal to name, so the verdict is obvious.
Verdict: ...Why was this gun even made?
Secondary Weapons
Pistol: Already given to Scout by default, so it has to be good.
Lugermorph: There isn't a difference. Just a promotional item for Sam & Max, then later for Poker Night at the Inventory.
Bonk! Atomic Punch: Who doesn't love a drink full of caffeine and sugar? I know Scout does.
Lugermorph: There isn't a difference. Just a promotional item for Sam & Max, then later for Poker Night at the Inventory.
Bonk! Atomic Punch: Who doesn't love a drink full of caffeine and sugar? I know Scout does.
This is cool because it has team colours. Not only that, but it's not half bad. In place of pistol, Scout receives a short-term invincibility boost (what we modern kids now-a-days call a "drug trip") which is useful to get past sentries, disable fire hurting for a short time or to escape certain death. The only downfall is the two-three second cutscene required for Scout to be able to use it. If this is interrupted, the can is still used but Scout does not get any effect.
While immune to damage, Scout will still experience knockback. There is a cooldown feature on this weapon to limit use and Scout cannot carry out objectives while "under the influence".
Verdict: It's a hard choice to make, considering it's very situational, but a good Scout will never need to use it.
Bonk! Crit-a-Cola: It's like the Bonk! Atomic Punches only it is purple. It could be an amalgamation of the two to show how the world would benefit by teams BLU and RED working together, or it could be just another energy drink.
Under the effect of Crit-a-Cola, Scout deals and receives min-crits on anything that hits him or his enemies. It's a very risk idea to use this weapon as a Pyro could easily incinerate Scout very quickly with mini-critical hit fire.
Same negative effects with Atomic Punch due to the cutscene when drinking it.
Verdict: Even more situational and extremely risky. Mini-critical hits really aren't worth betting on when Scout is the squishiest character out there. Stick with pistol.
Mad Milk: Of the situational weapons, this absolutely has to be the best one.
The first thing about this weapon to mention is that it's a white version of Jaraté. If Jaraté is full of Sniper's piss, then Mad Milk could only possibly be filled by Scout's...eugh...
That aside, this weapon is brilliant. It can put out fire on Scout or a teammate, as well as indicate a Spy's presence. Unlike Jaraté's critical function, Mad Milk returns 60% of damage done to an enemy back to Scout in the form of health. This can be quite useful.
Verdict: Situational, but a legitimate choice to make based on how many Pyros are in play and if the Scout in question often takes too much damage.
Winger: Like the pistol, this is a good choice as a farther-ranged weapon.
The clip size is reduced from twelve to five and there is a fifteen percent damage boost. Not that big of a boost for such a huge clip reduction. That's all there is to this weapon.
Verdict: Same as pistol but requires more reloading. Stay away unless looking for set bonus.
Verdict: Same as pistol but requires more reloading. Stay away unless looking for set bonus.
Tertiary Weapons/Melee
Bat: Just a traditional aluminium bat.
Sandman: Fairly interesting weapon choice. Wooden bat, not aluminium.
It gives the Scout the ability to hit a baseball with M2 and damage or stun (if far enough away). The effect increases the longer the shot is. The baseball has a cooldown as well. Besides that, the bat decreases a Scout's health by fifteen, which really isn't good. Scout is squishy enough as it is and the Sandman only makes it easier to kill one.
Verdict: If that Scout is good enough, this might be okay. Stunning is valuable, but life is more important.
Holy Mackerel: Just a fish in newspaper that does the same damage is the bat. Only difference is that the fish gives off the death notice "FISHKILL!" Fish are also better than bats, this is obviously the better choice.
Candy Cane: Surprisingly useful for a Christmas-themed item.
Sandman: Fairly interesting weapon choice. Wooden bat, not aluminium.
It gives the Scout the ability to hit a baseball with M2 and damage or stun (if far enough away). The effect increases the longer the shot is. The baseball has a cooldown as well. Besides that, the bat decreases a Scout's health by fifteen, which really isn't good. Scout is squishy enough as it is and the Sandman only makes it easier to kill one. Verdict: If that Scout is good enough, this might be okay. Stunning is valuable, but life is more important.
Holy Mackerel: Just a fish in newspaper that does the same damage is the bat. Only difference is that the fish gives off the death notice "FISHKILL!" Fish are also better than bats, this is obviously the better choice.
Candy Cane: Surprisingly useful for a Christmas-themed item.
Besides looking pretty, the candy cane drops a small health pack for Scout on any enemy kill, regardless of what was used to kill the enemy. Additionally, the candy cane decreases Scout's defense against explosions by 25%, which is not good if Demomen or Soldiers are around.
Verdict: Quite useful, really. Makes the healing powers of Mad Milk look a bit worse.
The Boston Basher: Well, Scout does come from Boston. Gotta represent.
This weapon is different than anything else so far. Scout can either hit an enemy and make them bleed for five seconds or miss, hit himself and bleed for five seconds. Sounds like a creepy BDSM tool to me. Anyway, it's insanely useful on jump maps as damage in mid-air allows Scout to almost glide when constantly regenerating. Not so great otherwise.
Verdict: Depends if the Scout is a masochist.
Sun-on-a-Stick: A promotional item for RIFT which isn't that good.
This weapon deals 25% less damage but 100% guarantees a critical hit if hitting a burning enemy. Not useful unless paired with a Pyro.
Verdict: Not really a practical weapon. Most Pyros can handle burning opponents themselves and 25% less damage really sucks.
Fan O'War: Again, a promotional item from Total War: SHOGUN 2 that sucks.
Verdict: Quite useful, really. Makes the healing powers of Mad Milk look a bit worse.
The Boston Basher: Well, Scout does come from Boston. Gotta represent.
This weapon is different than anything else so far. Scout can either hit an enemy and make them bleed for five seconds or miss, hit himself and bleed for five seconds. Sounds like a creepy BDSM tool to me. Anyway, it's insanely useful on jump maps as damage in mid-air allows Scout to almost glide when constantly regenerating. Not so great otherwise.
Verdict: Depends if the Scout is a masochist.
Sun-on-a-Stick: A promotional item for RIFT which isn't that good.
This weapon deals 25% less damage but 100% guarantees a critical hit if hitting a burning enemy. Not useful unless paired with a Pyro. Verdict: Not really a practical weapon. Most Pyros can handle burning opponents themselves and 25% less damage really sucks.
Fan O'War: Again, a promotional item from Total War: SHOGUN 2 that sucks.
This looks pretty snazzy and in reality it isn't even worth using. 90% of damage decrease over the regular bat for a fifteen second effect that every subsequent hit on that person will be mini-critical hits. Useful mostly on Medieval Degroot Keep maps. Verdict: Keep it away unless it's on the Medieval map.
Three Rune Blade: Lazy Robin Walker is lazy. Identical stats to Boston Basher.
Saxxy: Distributed to the most popular replays in TF2. Turns target into a gold statue on their death and has no other effect.
Atomizer: A cool new aluminium bat to try out.
More team colours! Woo! Also, this bat is useful on jump maps in that in can help Scout perform a third jump at the cost of ten health. However, bat speed is dropped by 30% and damage dealt is dropped by 20% so it's not a great choice outside jump maps.
Verdict: Keep it to the jump maps.
Closing and Recommendations
Ultimately, it's up to you what goes in your loadout, but based on this article, I would recommend:
Primary Slot: Scattergun
Secondary Slot: Pistol/Mad Milk
Tertiary/Melee Slot: Candy Cane I hope you enjoyed this review and I hope to do more in the future!
Primary Slot: Scattergun
Secondary Slot: Pistol/Mad Milk
Tertiary/Melee Slot: Candy Cane I hope you enjoyed this review and I hope to do more in the future!
